Discussion:
Joe Calzaghe
(too old to reply)
Eileen Foster
2003-07-30 04:26:29 UTC
Permalink
Who do you think would have won if Joe fought these guys in there prime?

Ben, Collins, Eubank, Watson.

And who was the best?
Jason Clark
2003-07-30 11:07:37 UTC
Permalink
Post by Eileen Foster
Who do you think would have won if Joe fought these guys in there prime?
Ben, Collins, Eubank, Watson.
And who was the best?
Seen them all fight and based on their prime performances, Eubank...just.

Joe needs a defining fight...yes he did beat Eubank but was past his best.
.::KoperniK::.
2003-07-30 12:54:58 UTC
Permalink
Post by Eileen Foster
Who do you think would have won if Joe fought these guys in there prime?
Ben, Collins, Eubank, Watson.
And who was the best?
Hate to see it but I can see all of them giving Joe a heck of a lot of
trouble - Eubank and Collins would beat him, Watson 50/50 and Benn? WHo
cares - the spectacle of the tear-up would be all that mattered :)

k
Walter Mitty
2003-07-30 23:15:22 UTC
Permalink
Post by Eileen Foster
Who do you think would have won if Joe fought these guys in there prime?
Ben, Collins, Eubank, Watson.
And who was the best?
Eubank was the best by a long shot. he was a classy fighter.

Calzaghe hasn't really been tested yet. There appear to be few American
pretty boys running scared of him since he's tough, unbeaten and hungry.
Not quite so pretty is also Axel Schultz who won't fight him unless it's in
front of 90000 Germans with a Bavarian judge and a rematch in Hamburg
clause.
--
Walter Mitty.
Mr.Will
2003-07-31 03:20:50 UTC
Permalink
Axel Shulz?
Dont you mean Sven Ottke?

Mr.Will
Post by Walter Mitty
Post by Eileen Foster
Who do you think would have won if Joe fought these guys in there prime?
Ben, Collins, Eubank, Watson.
And who was the best?
Eubank was the best by a long shot. he was a classy fighter.
Calzaghe hasn't really been tested yet. There appear to be few American
pretty boys running scared of him since he's tough, unbeaten and hungry.
Not quite so pretty is also Axel Schultz who won't fight him unless it's in
front of 90000 Germans with a Bavarian judge and a rematch in Hamburg
clause.
--
Walter Mitty.
Mr.Will
2003-07-31 03:20:09 UTC
Permalink
I think all but Collins would have beaten him.

Mr.Will
Post by Eileen Foster
Who do you think would have won if Joe fought these guys in there prime?
Ben, Collins, Eubank, Watson.
And who was the best?
Loading...